Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
fertility_and_religious_practice [2015/11/05 10:56]
marri
fertility_and_religious_practice [2017/11/30 15:10]
marri [3. The Role of Religious Practice]
Line 1: Line 1:
 ==========Fertility and Religious Practice========== ==========Fertility and Religious Practice==========
  
-In the last 150 years, the West has moved from a cultural norm of intact married religious family ​life to, increasingly, a norm of areligious ​and sexually promiscuous behavior. This model of human sexuality contains within its very conception both the erosion of the stable married family and declining openness to childrenA quantitative analysis of Europe shows that the abandonment of this model is necessary for the continuance of Western nations and peoples.+In the last several decades, the [[state_of_the_family_in_america|intact married religious family]] has diminished as the cultural norm in the Western world. ​ What weakened it—extra-marital and non-marital sexual practices, a rejection ​of childbearing,​ and areligious ​sentiments—has prompted ​fertility crisisThe continuance of Western nations and peoples ​depends on the restoration of [[effects_of_religious_practice_on_society|religious worship]] and sexual mores 
  
 =====1. Fertility Trends in Europe===== =====1. Fertility Trends in Europe=====
Line 9: Line 9:
 {{ :​fertility_in_europe.png?​direct&​400 |Total Fertility Rates in Europe}} {{ :​fertility_in_europe.png?​direct&​400 |Total Fertility Rates in Europe}}
  
-The below chart from 2001 illustrates the difference between the attained fertility of European women depending on their age,((A newly formed marriage of a 20 year-old woman receives nearly a full weight (100 percent) on the y-axis, as that marriage has the potential to bring many children into the world if contraceptive means are not employed. A new marriage formed by a 50 year-old woman would receive no weight (0 percent) as that marriage statistically will not bring children into the world.)) compared to their potential fertility (which was gauged by the actual fertility of Hutterite women).((The upper, blue curve in this chart is a sociologically---not biologically---determined potential fertility. It is the fertility achieved by an Anabaptist sect settled in the north-central United States which adhered to a religious prohibition of contraceptives. This depiction of high fertility also represents with some faithfulness the traditional delay of marriage (and fertility in marriage) seen in Western societies.)) The number of children actually born (red area) is a much smaller percent of the number of potential children (blue area). ​+The below chart from 2001 illustrates the difference between the attained fertility of European women depending on their age,((A newly formed marriage of a 20 year-old woman receives nearly a full weight (100 percent) on the y-axis, as that marriage has the potential to bring many children into the world if contraceptive means are not employed. A new marriage formed by a 50 year-old woman would receive no weight (0 percent) as that marriage statistically will not bring children into the world. \\ See Henry Potrykus and Patrick Fagan, //Marriage, Contraception & The Future of Western Peoples//, Marriage and Religion Research Institute (2011). Available at [[http://​marri.us/​research/​research-papers/​marriage-contraception-the-future-of-western-peoples/​]].)) compared to their potential fertility (which was gauged by the actual fertility of Hutterite women).((The upper, blue curve in this chart is a sociologically---not biologically---determined potential fertility. It is the fertility achieved by an Anabaptist sect settled in the north-central United States which adhered to a religious prohibition of contraceptives. This depiction of high fertility also represents with some faithfulness the traditional delay of marriage (and fertility in marriage) seen in Western societies.)) The number of children actually born (red area) is a much smaller percent of the number of potential children (blue area). ​
  
 {{ :​married_female_fertility.png?​direct&​350 |Married Female Fertility}} {{ :​married_female_fertility.png?​direct&​350 |Married Female Fertility}}
Line 22: Line 22:
 {{ :​major_cultural_transitions_effects.png?​direct&​600 |Major Cultural Transitions'​ Effects}} {{ :​major_cultural_transitions_effects.png?​direct&​600 |Major Cultural Transitions'​ Effects}}
  
-Taking hold after the on-set of industrialization in the West, the contraceptive mindset (fewer children) is of one cloth with the West shifting its economic orientation from family enterprise to individualist labor activity while simultaneously moving from religious to secular social values.((Ron Lesthaeghe and Chris Wilson, “Modes of Production, Secularization,​ and the Pace of the Fertility Decline in Western Europe, 1870-1930,"​ in //The Decline of Fertility in Europe//, ​ed. by Ansley Coale and Susan Cotts Watkins ​(Princeton University Press, 1986) Chapter 6. \\ Theresa Notare, “A Revolution in Christian Morals: Lambeth 1930, Resolution 15—History and Reception,"​ PhD Thesis at the Catholic University of America, 2008.))  ​+Taking hold after the on-set of industrialization in the West, the contraceptive mindset (fewer children) is of one cloth with the West shifting its economic orientation from family enterprise to individualist labor activity while simultaneously moving from religious to secular social values.((Ron Lesthaeghe and Chris Wilson, “Modes of Production, Secularization,​ and the Pace of the Fertility Decline in Western Europe, 1870-1930,"​ in ed. by Ansley Coale and Susan Cotts Watkins ​//The Decline of Fertility in Europe//, (Princeton University Press, 1986) Chapter 6. \\ Theresa Notare, “A Revolution in Christian Morals: Lambeth 1930, Resolution 15—History and Reception,"​ PhD Thesis at the Catholic University of America, 2008.))  ​
  
-The marriage trend has been less consistent. Current sexual-revolution norms have deeply reduced the propensity to marry.((Mark Regnerus, “Sex is Cheap,” //Slate// (February 2011) available ​at [[http://​www.slate.com/​articles/​double_x/​doublex/​2011/​02/​sex_is_cheap.html]]. \\ Joseph Anthony Burke and Catherine Pakaluk, ​//The Contraceptive Revolution and the Second Demographic Transition: An Economic Model of Sex, Fertility, and Marriage//Ave Maria University, no. 1003 (2010).)) Governments,​ the U.N., International Planned Parenthood, Marie Stopes and other foundations,​ as well as all who have adopted the new model of how society is to function, continue to work to establish these polymorphous sexual norms. In the past, and especially during the marriage boom of the 1950s (center chart below),​((John Hajnal, ​The Marriage Boom, //​Population Studies// 7.2 (1953): 111-136.)) there was a tendency toward earlier and long-lasting marriage. This tendency and its appreciation of the importance of the family allowed for replacement rates of fertility, seen especially in the ‘baby boom’ of the marriage boom.+The marriage trend has been less consistent. Current sexual-revolution norms have deeply reduced the propensity to marry.((Mark Regnerus, “Sex is Cheap,” //Slate// (February 2011). Available ​at [[http://​www.slate.com/​articles/​double_x/​doublex/​2011/​02/​sex_is_cheap.html]]. \\ Joseph Anthony Burke and Catherine Pakaluk, ​"The Contraceptive Revolution and the Second Demographic Transition: An Economic Model of Sex, Fertility, and Marriage," ​//Ave Maria University//, no. 1003 (2010).)) Governments,​ the U.N., International Planned Parenthood, Marie Stopes and other foundations,​ as well as all who have adopted the new model of how society is to function, continue to work to establish these polymorphous sexual norms. In the past, and especially during the marriage boom of the 1950s (center chart below),​((John Hajnal, ​"The Marriage Boom," ​//​Population Studies// 7, no. 2 (1953): 111-136.)) there was a tendency toward earlier and long-lasting marriage. This tendency and its [[effects.of.marriage.on.couples.relationships|appreciation of the importance of the family]] allowed for replacement rates of fertility, seen especially in the ‘baby boom’ of the marriage boom.
  
 This information is condensed in the chart below. The evolution of views on marriage and contraception in the West has resulted in fertility levels far below the needed replacement number of successors. It now approaches 1.5 children per couple, which is much less than the required 2.1. This information is condensed in the chart below. The evolution of views on marriage and contraception in the West has resulted in fertility levels far below the needed replacement number of successors. It now approaches 1.5 children per couple, which is much less than the required 2.1.
Line 36: Line 36:
 Review of the literature shows that only one variable consistently delivers fertility rates at or above replacement level: regular religious worship, especially weekly religious worship. Review of the literature shows that only one variable consistently delivers fertility rates at or above replacement level: regular religious worship, especially weekly religious worship.
  
-John Mueller of The Ethics and Public Policy Institute (EPPI) in Washington DC, has done significant work on this issue as he set out to correct a gaping hole in modern economic theory: measuring, understanding and explaining the causes of a significant portion of the economy—namely,​ that economic activity which is not governed by the laws of price and exchange but rather by a motivation very different from that of personal gain or advantage. In his book //Redeeming Economics: Rediscovering the Missing Element//, Mueller found that the vast proportion of economic activity is motivated by altruism or selflessness. Even more significant,​ in his chapter on fertility, Mueller draws attention to the rather glaring and for someuncomfortable demographic:​ the only variable that yields increased fertility is weekly religious worship.+John Mueller of The Ethics and Public Policy Institute (EPPI) in Washington DC, has done significant work on this issue as he set out to correct a gaping hole in modern economic theory: measuring, understanding and explaining the causes of a significant portion of the economy—namely,​ that economic activity which is not governed by the laws of price and exchange but rather by a motivation very different from that of personal gain or advantage. In his book//Redeeming Economics: Rediscovering the Missing Element//, Mueller found that the vast proportion of economic activity is motivated by altruism or selflessness. Even more significant,​ in his chapter on fertility, Mueller draws attention to the rather glaring and for some uncomfortable demographic:​ the only variable that yields increased fertility is weekly ​[[effects_of_religious_practice_on_society|religious worship]].((John D. Mueller, //Redeeming Economics: Rediscovering the Missing Element//, (Wilmington,​ DE: ISI Books, 2010).))
  
 In the below chart Mueller shows that increased social spending by governments is significantly correlated with //​decreased//​ fertility. It also demonstrates that totalitarian governments rather consistently yield fertility rates slightly above 1.0. In the below chart Mueller shows that increased social spending by governments is significantly correlated with //​decreased//​ fertility. It also demonstrates that totalitarian governments rather consistently yield fertility rates slightly above 1.0.
Line 48: Line 48:
 Mueller elegantly develops and deftly illustrates at the macro level the differential impacts of two opposing elements that vie within the heart of all parents: a selfless giving to their children for the benefit of their children, and the competing element of ‘giving to their children for their own personal benefit’ (such as to be taken care of in their old age). Mueller elegantly develops and deftly illustrates at the macro level the differential impacts of two opposing elements that vie within the heart of all parents: a selfless giving to their children for the benefit of their children, and the competing element of ‘giving to their children for their own personal benefit’ (such as to be taken care of in their old age).
  
-Mueller comments, “The problems just recounted are the inevitable result of attempting to explain anything so fundamental as fertility ---the reproduction of human persons---without the element of economic theory that describes one’s preferences for persons” (236). ​+Mueller comments, “The problems just recounted are the inevitable result of attempting to explain anything so fundamental as fertility ---the reproduction of human persons---without the element of economic theory that describes one’s preferences for persons” ((//​Redeeming Economics//, ​236)). 
  
 The below chart illustrates the positive relationship between frequency of weekly religious practice and national fertility rates. The below chart illustrates the positive relationship between frequency of weekly religious practice and national fertility rates.
Line 54: Line 54:
 {{ :​weekly_worship_v._fertility.png?​direct&​600 |Weekly Worship vs. Fertility}} {{ :​weekly_worship_v._fertility.png?​direct&​600 |Weekly Worship vs. Fertility}}
  
-The more frequently people worship God, across all religions and nations, the more likely they are to give selflessly. ​ As we have seen, a 100 percent rate of weekly religious worship yields 2.1 more children per mother or per family. According to Mueller, ​ +The more frequently people worship God, across all religions and nations, the more likely they are to [[effects_of_religious_practice_on_society|give selflessly]].  As we have seen, a 100 percent rate of weekly ​[[effects_of_religious_practice_on_family_relationships|religious worship yields 2.1 more children]] per mother or per family. According to Mueller, ​"After purely selfish factors are accounted for, acting on belief in God and some kind of afterlife makes the crucial difference as to whether people reproduce themselves. ​ It suggests that the personal gift of time and resources involved in worship is closely and systematically associated with the personal gift of having children for their own sake rather than for the pleasure and utility of the parents" ​((//​Redeeming Economics//, ​238-239)).
-After purely selfish factors are accounted for, acting on belief in God and some kind of afterlife makes the crucial difference as to whether people reproduce themselves. ​ It suggests that the personal gift of time and resources involved in worship is closely and systematically associated with the personal gift of having children for their own sake rather than for the pleasure and utility of the parents(238-239)+
  
 The total fertility rate (TFR) in countries where the rate of weekly worship is close to zero is 1.25.  Where weekly worship is 100 percent, the net TFR is 3.4, or 2.1 children higher.  ​ The total fertility rate (TFR) in countries where the rate of weekly worship is close to zero is 1.25.  Where weekly worship is 100 percent, the net TFR is 3.4, or 2.1 children higher.  ​
Line 63: Line 62:
 Why does this happen? Because it includes the missing element of modern, neoclassical economics (in their task of oversimplified theory of Adam Smith). The missing element is the law of the gift or the valuing of other persons, at least at times, more than valuing oneself. Why does this happen? Because it includes the missing element of modern, neoclassical economics (in their task of oversimplified theory of Adam Smith). The missing element is the law of the gift or the valuing of other persons, at least at times, more than valuing oneself.
  
-A very significant portion of economic activity is undertaken not for exchange or profit but to give to others for the benefit of others. The largest example of this form of economic activity is the obvious, very frequent, and very foundational activity of all economies: the economic activity of parents when they give existence to children, rear them, and instruct them or provide for their education. Another significant example is “works of charity.”+A very significant portion of economic activity is undertaken not for exchange or profitbut to give to others for the benefit of others. The largest example of this form of economic activity is the obvious, very frequent, and very foundational activity of all economies: the economic activity of parents when they give existence to children, rear them, and instruct them or provide for their [[effects_of_family_structure_on_children_s_education|education]]. Another significant example is “works of charity.”
  
 {{ :​total_fertility_rate-_predicted_v._actual.png?​direct&​600 |Total Fertility Rate: Predicted vs. Actual}} {{ :​total_fertility_rate-_predicted_v._actual.png?​direct&​600 |Total Fertility Rate: Predicted vs. Actual}}
  
-However, as the below chart from the “Win-Gallop ​International Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism (2012)” illustrates,​ most countries are experiencing a significant decline in rates of religiosity (not exactly the same as weekly religious worship, but a closely related indicator).+However, as the below chart from the "International Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism"​((Ijaz Shafi, Gilani, Rushna Shahid, and Irene Zuettel, "​Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism,"​ WIN-Gallup //Gallup International// ​(2012). Available at [[http://​www.wingia.com/​web/​files/​news/​14/​file/​14.pdf]].)) ​illustrates,​ most countries are experiencing a significant decline in rates of religiosity (not exactly the same as weekly religious worship, but a closely related indicator).
  
 The implication of these data and insights is significant:​ Europe (and other nations) face the choice of a return to worshipping God or gradually declining. ​ The implication of these data and insights is significant:​ Europe (and other nations) face the choice of a return to worshipping God or gradually declining. ​
Line 116: Line 115:
 |Japan |17% |16% |-1% | |Japan |17% |16% |-1% |
  
-For instance, the following chart based on the Add Health Survey---a U.S. federally funded longitudinal survey of youth with an initial sample size exceeding 16,000 students---illustrates the education performance of U.S. children in high school ​(combined Math and English Grade Point Average). The more frequent their rates of worship, the better they perform, ​on average.  ​+For instance, the following chart based on the Add Health Survey---a U.S. federally funded longitudinal survey of youth with an initial sample size exceeding 16,000 students---illustrates the education performance of U.S. children in high school. The more frequent their rates of worship, the [[effects_of_religious_practice_on_education|better they tend to perform]] (herespecifically,​ in terms of their combined Math and English Grade Point Average).  ​
  
 {{ :​wcf_average_english_math.png?​direct&​450 |Average GPA English/ Math Combined}} {{ :​wcf_average_english_math.png?​direct&​450 |Average GPA English/ Math Combined}}
  
-=====4. A New Social Policy====+This is especially important for [[effects_of_religious_practice_on_poor_communities|disadvantaged youth]]. Frequency of worship (blue line) is one of the strongest beneficial factors in raising education outcomes for the poorest children in the inner-cities of America. Most of these disadvantaged children live in families headed by single mothers. 
 + 
 +{{ :​wcf_poor_communities_education.png?​direct&​450 |Neighborhood Poverty and Academic On-Track Performance}} 
 + 
 +=====4. Trends Among Particular Religious Denominations===== 
 +Although Christianity is the largest religious denomination in the world, declining fertility rates—particularly in Europe((Hackett,​ Conrade and David McClendon, "​Christians Remain World'​s Largest Religious Group, But They Are Declining in Europe,"​ Pew Research Center (April 2017), available at [[http://​www.pewresearch.org/​fact-tank/​2017/​04/​05/​christians-remain-worlds-largest-religious-group-but-they-are-declining-in-europe/​]].))—indicate that this may no longer be the case by 2060.((Lipka,​ Michael and Conrad Hackett, "Why Muslims Are the World'​s Fastest Growing Religious Group,"​ Pew Research Center (April 2017), available at [[http://​www.pewresearch.org/​fact-tank/​2017/​04/​06/​why-muslims-are-the-worlds-fastest-growing-religious-group/​]].)) Religious Nones are also projected to decline as a share of the world’s population due to their exceptionally low fertility rate.((Pew Research Center, April 5, 2017, “The Changing Global Religious Landscape,​” available at [[http://​assets.pewresearch.org/​wp-content/​uploads/​sites/​11/​2017/​04/​07092755/​FULL-REPORT-WITH-APPENDIXES-A-AND-B-APRIL-3.pdf]].)) Muslims, who had the highest fertility rate of all religious denominations and made up roughly 31 percent of all births from 2010-2015, will likely replace Christians.((Pew Research Center, April 5, 2017, “The Changing Global Religious Landscape,​” available at [[http://​assets.pewresearch.org/​wp-content/​uploads/​sites/​11/​2017/​04/​07092755/​FULL-REPORT-WITH-APPENDIXES-A-AND-B-APRIL-3.pdf]]. 
 +\\ 
 +\\ 
 +\\ 
 +This entry draws heavily from John D. Mueller, //Redeeming Economics: Rediscovering the Missing Element//, (Wilmington,​ DE: ISI Books, 2010) and [[http://​marri.us/​research/​research-papers/​marriage-contraception-the-future-of-western-peoples/​| "​Marriage,​ Contraception & The Future of Western Peoples"​]].)) 
 + 
 +=====5. A New Social Policy====
  
 On every outcome measured by the U.S. statistical system---and frequency of worship is one of the variables measured in at least eight different major federal surveys---the more frequent the rate of worship, ​ the better the persons tend to do on positive outcomes. For undesirable outcomes the opposite holds: the more frequent people worship, the less frequent their negative outcomes. On every outcome measured by the U.S. statistical system---and frequency of worship is one of the variables measured in at least eight different major federal surveys---the more frequent the rate of worship, ​ the better the persons tend to do on positive outcomes. For undesirable outcomes the opposite holds: the more frequent people worship, the less frequent their negative outcomes.
Line 126: Line 136:
 An additional variable further affects the impact of religious practice: family structure. Scholars across the political spectrum, at least as manifested in the major Washington think tanks, agree that on every outcome both adults and children in the intact married family do best. An additional variable further affects the impact of religious practice: family structure. Scholars across the political spectrum, at least as manifested in the major Washington think tanks, agree that on every outcome both adults and children in the intact married family do best.
  
-Demographically in the United States, the intact married family that worships God weekly does best on every outcome measured, while the non-intact family that does not worship does worst. The other two structures—the intact married family that does not worship at all, and the broken family that worships weekly—fall in the middle. On different outcomes they trade places for second and third place. Observing the patterns is quite instructive:​ on matters of self-control such as issues of sex, alcohol, drugs and anger or violence -- frequency of worship is powerfully protective. On matters related to income intact marriage is powerful. ​+Demographically in the United States, the intact married family that worships God weekly does best on every outcome measured, while the non-intact family that does not worship does worst. The other two structures—the intact married family that does not worship at all, and the broken family that worships weekly—fall in the middle. On different outcomes they trade places for second and third place. Observing the patterns is quite instructive:​ on matters of self-control such as issues of sex, alcohol, drugs and anger or violence -- frequency of worship is powerfully protective. On matters related to incomeintact marriage is powerful. ​
  
 The public policy experiment of moderate socialism in the last 60 years has failed in many instances to grow the social and human capital of its people, despite its success in redistributing a significant portion of national material wealth. ​ The public policy experiment of moderate socialism in the last 60 years has failed in many instances to grow the social and human capital of its people, despite its success in redistributing a significant portion of national material wealth. ​
Line 132: Line 142:
 A new social policy that is very simple yet very powerful would prove far more productive: Grow the young intact married family that worships God weekly. A new social policy that is very simple yet very powerful would prove far more productive: Grow the young intact married family that worships God weekly.
  
-The nations that succeed in growing the young intact married family that worships God weekly will undoubtedly prosper in all the social outcomes desired by the modern welfare state. These nations will reap the benefits in such desirable outcomes as increased education attainment, income, productivity,​ savings, health, longevity, mental health, happiness, stability of marriages and happy children. These nations will experience increased fertility, and its citizens will find greater sexual enjoyment.  ​+The nations that succeed in growing the young intact married family that worships God weekly will undoubtedly prosper in all the social outcomes desired by the modern welfare state. These nations will reap the benefits in such desirable outcomes as increased ​[[effects.of.marriage.on.children.s.education|education]] attainment, ​[[effects_of_family_structure_on_income|income]][[effects_of_marriage_on_workforce_participation|productivity]][[effects_of_family_structure_on_the_economy|savings]][[effects_of_marriage_on_physical_health|health]], longevity, ​[[effects.of.marriage.on.mental.health|mental health]], happiness, ​[[effects.of.marriage.on.couples.relationships|stability of marriages]] and happy children. These nations will experience increased fertility, and its citizens will find greater sexual enjoyment.  ​
  
 {{ :​positive_feelings_during_intercourse.png?​direct&​500 |Positive Feelings During Intercourse}} {{ :​positive_feelings_during_intercourse.png?​direct&​500 |Positive Feelings During Intercourse}}
  
-Clearly, this social strategy cannot be executed by governments;​ it relies on the nation as a whole, and will only be attained by cooperation among family, school and church (and synagogue, mosque, and temple). ​ The government’s main role would be to give these three fundamental institutions (family, church and school) the space to cooperate with each other in forming the future generation, the children. This social policy is motivated by a deep desire to serve others with time, attention, talent, and wealth. ​+Clearly, this social strategy cannot be executed by governments;​ it relies on the nation as a whole, and will only be attained by cooperation among family, school and church (and synagogue, mosque, and temple). The government’s main role would be to give these three fundamental institutions (family, church and school) the space to cooperate with each other in forming the future generation, the children. This social policy is motivated by a deep desire to serve others with time, attention, talent, and wealth. ​